TechWhirl (TECHWR-L) is a resource for technical writing and technical communications professionals of all experience levels and in all industries to share their experiences and acquire information.
For two decades, technical communicators have turned to TechWhirl to ask and answer questions about the always-changing world of technical communications, such as tools, skills, career paths, methodologies, and emerging industries. The TechWhirl Archives and magazine, created for, by and about technical writers, offer a wealth of knowledge to everyone with an interest in any aspect of technical communications.
Subject:Frame vs Word - ERRATUM From:Michael LaTorra <mikel -at- HUEY -dot- ACCUGRAPH -dot- COM> Date:Tue, 17 Jan 1995 13:18:12 MST
ERRATUM: I accidentally transposed some text in the Comparison Table of
FrameMaker and Word that I posted under the message title "SUMMARY -
Frame vs Word". The errors occurred in the rows "tables" and "printing".
A corrected table is included below. And I'd like to thank those sharp-
eyed readers who caught these errors and informed me. Hats off to:
Carol Odlum, Becky Day, M. Brown ("Vidiot"), Colin Evans, and
Bertrand Decouty.
One more thing: More responses to my original posting have been
coming in. After a decent interval (i.e., when I have time),
I will summarize these as well.
Live long & prosper,
Mike LaTorra
Documentation Supervisor
Accugraph Inc.
mikel -at- accugraph -dot- com
.............................................................................
Comparison Table of FrameMaker and Word
_______________________________________________________________________________
FUNCTION FRAME v4 WORD v6
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
platforms PC, Mac, UNIX PC, Mac
application Desk Top Publisher Word Processor
type
speed fast slow
books designed for this; not designed for this;
(multi-file) 1,000 pages are OK; 100 pages are barely possible;
easy to create & 1,000 pages are out of the question
maintain, including extremely slow to process/update;
pagination difficult to control pagination
between files in book
templates comprehensive, robust, limited, difficult to modify once
easy to use and modify in use
mixed page easy to combine combining different layouts in the
layouts different layouts same document tends to crash Word
in one document
paragraph easy to apply, modify; easy to apply; user can not define
tags user can define number number of lines in widow/orphan control
of lines in widow/
orphan control
character user can define user can define
tags
hyphenation robust; allows weak; does not allow non-breaking
non-breaking hyphen hyphen
version uses Conditional Text multiple file sets must be maintained
control to maintain different
doc. versions in same
file
references index, cross-ref., cross-references can cause problems;
easy to create & updating references is extremely slow
update
tables table formats can be each instance must be formatted
created & saved; individually
2 predefined
formats included
graphics adequate tools for limited tools; outside graphic app.
most purposes usually required
image capture built-in function - none -
sorting - none - supported for tables, lists, paragraphs
printing supports registration no registration marks, thumbnails,
marks, thumbnails, color separations
color separations